Ticket #181 (new defect)
Regression fixes by draqo
| Reported by: | arend | Owned by: | gnugo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Priority: | normal | Milestone: | 3.9.x |
| Component: | regressions | Version: | |
| Severity: | normal | Keywords: | |
| Cc: | patch: | yes |
Description
This extracts the regression fixes out of all-in-one.zip in #148. (It supersedes reg_tests.diff there.)
Attachments
Regression Results
| Attachment | Rev. | PASS | FAIL | Nodes | Status | |
| draqo-regress.diff | 2382 | 0% 0% 0% | details |
Change History
Changed 5 years ago by arend
-
attachment
draqo-regress.diff
added
comment:1 Changed 4 years ago by gunnar
# G13 is still sufficient to get a seki. +# +# After N6 the game could be: +# N7 K12 G13 J13 N5 M3 L13 N4 H13 N6 +# and now white has to win extremely unforable 3 stage ko, +# so this move could be acceptable - G13 and K12 leads to +# the similar position - so the best move is N5, which +# doesn't allow white making a ko. loadsgf games/kgs/tournament11/CrazyStone-GNU.sgf 87 43 reg_genmove black -#? [G13] +#? [G13|K12|N6|N5]
I suspect this test is at the wrong move. Even with a tenuki white can't do better with the semeai than a bad ko which doesn't win the game. G13, J13, K12, N5, M3, N3, M2, K3, J5 all give seki without ko whereas N6 leaves the small ko aji mentioned above. At move 89 tenuki leaves white with a sufficiently good ko to win the game, N5, M3, N3, M2, K3, J5 give a clean seki and win for black, whereas J13, K12, and N6 suffice to win but leave a small ko aji.
comment:2 Changed 4 years ago by gunnar
loadsgf games/incident161.sgf 42 28 owl_attack B8 #? [1 C7] +# after E9 C7 F9 there is a seki 29 owl_defend B8 -#? [1 C7] +#? [1 (C7|E9)] 30 owl_attack D8 #? [1 C7] +# same as 29 31 owl_defend D8 -#? [1 C7] +#? [1 (C7|E9)]
The owl code is unlikely to understand the seki but fair enough, E9 works.
comment:3 Changed 4 years ago by gunnar
--- regression/strategy2.tst (revision 2379) +++ regression/strategy2.tst (working copy) @@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ loadsgf games/strategy14.sgf 125 55 reg_genmove white -#? [C12]* +#? [C12|B13]
I don't like the shape of B13 but it looks like it works.
# This is essentially a semeai problem loadsgf games/strategy22.sgf 80 reg_genmove white -#? [P4|Q4|Q3|S8] +#? [P4|Q4|Q3|S8|R6]
R6 is fine.
comment:4 Changed 4 years ago by gunnar
--- regression/arb.tst (revision 2379) +++ regression/arb.tst (working copy) @@ -66,7 +66,7 @@ # Defend against a combination attack. loadsgf games/arb/game03.sgf 109 232 reg_genmove black -#? [M9|M10|L10|L11] +#? [M9|M10|M11|L10|L11]
M11 is kind of ugly but it does work.
comment:5 Changed 4 years ago by gunnar
--- regression/nngs4.tst (revision 2379) +++ regression/nngs4.tst (working copy) @@ -249,7 +249,7 @@ #C13 looks correct here /evand loadsgf games/nngs/gnugo-3.3.10-niki-200210281349.sgf 144 610 reg_genmove white -#? [C13|D13] +#? [C13|D13|B14]
I don't like B14. Looks like bad shape and leaves white a reverse sente move at D13 with good followup.

Supersedes reg_tests.diff in #148